Influence
Architects Ranked by what they changed. Courses in the book, championships those courses have held, and whether later architects copied them. It is a judgment, not a count — a man with one course can outrank a firm with twenty.
1 Alister MacKenzie 1870–1934 · 9 in the book Augusta, Cypress Point, and Crystal Downs. The pictures people mean when they say a course looks like it was found. With Bobby Jones, the Masters course. With the dunes at Cypress, the most famous short hole in America. 2 Donald Ross 1872–1948 · 37 in the book Pinehurst No. 2, Seminole, Oakland Hills, Oak Hill, Aronimink. Crowned greens and more American golf than any other single hand. The sandhills template. If a green sheds, someone in the group will say Ross whether or not he built it. 3 A.W. Tillinghast 1876–1942 · 15 in the book Winged Foot, Bethpage, Baltusrol, Quaker Ridge, San Francisco. Championship parkland with a mean green and a fairway that asks for a shape. The man the USGA and the PGA keep returning to when they want a test that already existed. 4 C.B. Macdonald 1855–1939 · 7 in the book National Golf Links and Chicago Golf. He brought the templates home — Redan, Alps, Eden, Cape — and made American architecture literate. The first 18-hole club in the country, and the course on Long Island that taught everyone else the vocabulary. 5 Seth Raynor 1874–1926 · 13 in the book Macdonald’s engineer, and then the man who actually built the language: Fishers Island, Camargo, Yeamans Hall, Shoreacres. Died young and still left a school. The Biarritz green is his signature even when his name is second on the plaque. 6 Pete Dye 1925–2020 · 32 in the book Sawgrass, Kiawah, Whistling Straits, Harbour Town, the Honors Course. Railroad ties, angles, and a hazard you can see from the tee and still find. With Alice Dye, he made strategy visible. The island green is the hole the whole country can draw from memory. 7 William Flynn 1890–1944 · 7 in the book Shinnecock Hills as the Open course, and a restoring hand on ground that was already famous. He understood wind as a design material. The national championship keeps going back to his Shinnecock. That is the accolade. 8 Coore & Crenshaw Since 1985 · 17 in the book Sand Hills restarted American architecture. Friar’s Head, Bandon Trails, and the Pinehurst restoration followed from the same idea: find the golf, don’t invent the scenery. The firm every minimalist is either working with or working against. 9 George C. Thomas Jr. 1873–1932 · 3 in the book Riviera and Los Angeles Country Club’s North Course. Two masterpieces in one city, then he went back to his roses. A bunker in the middle of a green, a barranca used as strategy, and almost no other courses. The restraint is the ranking. 10 Perry Maxwell 1879–1952 · 5 in the book Prairie Dunes, Southern Hills, and the greens at Augusta he was asked to touch. The “Maxwell roll” is a green that moves without announcing itself. Prairie Dunes is the inland links people in the plains will stack against anywhere. 11 Tom Doak Born 1961 · 16 in the book Pacific Dunes, and a generation of builders who read his criticism before they routed a hole. He made the walk part of the design. Thirteen greens in sight of the Pacific at Bandon, and a restoration practice as serious as the originals. 12 Robert Trent Jones Sr. 1906–2000 · 19 in the book The championship formula of the television age: longer, wetter, and built to hold a major. Peachtree, Hazeltine, Bellerive, and the remaking of other men’s courses. He is why “Open doctor” became a job. His son Rees inherited the practice. 13 Jack Nicklaus Born 1940 · 30 in the book Muirfield Village is the course. The rest of the practice is the player as architect, which changed who clubs hired and what they thought they were buying. The Memorial, and a design signature — heroism over water — that the tour still sets up on Sunday. 14 Gil Hanse Born 1963 · 8 in the book The restoration architect of this century, and the man the Olympics called. He puts courses back toward the person who first saw the ground. Aronimink, Los Angeles, the Olympic course in Rio, Pinehurst No. 4. The work is the opposite of a signature. 15 Hugh Wilson 1879–1925 · 2 in the book Merion East. One course, a quarry, wicker baskets, and a place in every argument about the best eighteen in the country. He studied the classics and came home with something that still hosts championships on a small piece of the Main Line. 16 Tom Fazio Born 1945 · 58 in the book Shadow Creek, Wade Hampton, and the modern idea that a resort course can feel discovered even when every tree was placed. The highest green fees in the desert and the mountains tend to have his name on them. That is a kind of influence. 17 George Crump & H.S. Colt Crump 1871–1918 · 1 in the book Pine Valley. Crump spent himself on one course in the New Jersey sand. Colt consulted. It is still the consensus first course in this book. Not a weak hole. That sentence is either the ranking or a provocation, and the book still leads with it. 18 David McLay Kidd Born 1967 · 6 in the book Bandon Dunes opened the public links coast. Everything that came after on that cliff — Doak, Coore, the resort as a pilgrimage — starts with his first routing. He made a Scottish links argument on the Oregon coast and convinced the country to fly there. 19 Tiger Woods Born 1975 · 2 in the book Payne’s Valley is the course in this book. TGR Design’s first public eighteen, in the Missouri Ozarks at Big Cedar, named for Payne Stewart. The ranking is not the trophy case. It is that a player-architect’s course showed up as a place anyone can book. The nineteenth hole is a short par three to an island green, with Stewart’s statue on the tee. The eighteen in front of it is the argument. Also in the book The rest of the credits, ordered by how often they appear. Not a second ranking.
Robert Trent Jones Jr. 14 Arnold Palmer 12 Rees Jones 12 Tom Weiskopf 10 Mike Strantz 6 Hurdzan & Fry 5 Arthur Hills 4 Bobby Weed 4 Dick Wilson 4 George Fazio 4 Walter Travis 4 Brian Silva 3 Charles Banks 3 Herbert Strong 3 Jim Engh 3 John Fought 3 Johnny Miller 3 Roger Rulewich 3 William F. Bell 3 Willie Park Jr. 3 Willie Watson 3 Bob Cupp 2 Chet Williams 2 Devereux Emmet 2 Ellis Maples 2 Fred Couples 2 Greg Norman 2 Jay Morrish 2 Jeff Brauer 2 Jeffrey Brauer 2 Langford & Moreau 2 Lawrence Packard 2 Lester George 2 Mike DeVries 2 Scott Miller 2 Tom Bendelow 2 Tom Lehman 2 William Watson 2 Alex Findlay 1 Baxter Spann 1 Brian Ault 1 Brian Schneider 1 Bruce Devlin 1 C.H. Alison 1 Charles E. Clarke 1 Dan Hixson 1 Dana Fry 1 Dave Axland 1 David Graham 1 David Harman 1 Dennis Rider 1 Dick Bailey 1 Dick Nugent 1 Dick Phelps 1 Donald Steel 1 Emerson Armstrong 1 Eric Bergstol 1 Ernie Els 1 Gary Martin 1 Gary Panks 1 Gary Roger Baird 1 Gene Bates 1 Geoffrey Cornish 1 George Cobb 1 George Junor 1 Graham Marsh 1 H. Chandler Egan 1 H.C. Leeds 1 H.S. Colt 1 Harrison Frazar 1 Henry C. Fownes 1 Herbert Fowler 1 Homer Flint 1 Jack Neville 1 Jerry Pate 1 Jerry Rich 1 Jim Fazio 1 John Harbottle 1 John Raese 1 Keith Foster 1 Ken Dye 1 Kyle Franz 1 Lindsay Ervin 1 Mark McCumber 1 Mark Mungeam 1 Mike Asmundson 1 Mike Benkusky 1 Military course 1 Nipper Campbell 1 Robert Cupp 1 Robert Lawrence 1 Robert Muir Graves 1 Rod Whitman 1 Sam Whiting 1 Scott Hoffman 1 Scott Hoffmann 1 Steve Smyers 1 Tad King 1 Ted Robinson 1 Tom Watson 1 Tom Winton 1 Warren Henderson 1 Wayne Stiles 1 Wilfrid Reid 1 William F. Davis 1 William F. Gordon 1 Willie Campbell 1 Willie Locke 1